SHOCKING! Gutfeld stuns fans once again with a bold ultimatum: he’ll walk away from The Five if Fox doesn’t fire “that woman”: “I will not share the screen with her.” – Don’t miss, check comments

SHOCKING! Gutfeld stuns fans once again with a bold ultimatum: he’ll walk away from The Five if Fox doesn’t fire “that woman”: “I will not share the screen with her.” – Don’t miss, check comments

**SHOCKING! Gutfeld Issues Ultimatum: “I Will Not Share the Screen with Her”**

Fox News insiders and media watchers were stunned when Greg Gutfeld reportedly issued a dramatic ultimatum: he will walk away from *The Five* unless one of his co‑hosts, Jessica Tarlov, is removed. He said plainly, “I will not share the screen with her.” ([The News Scroll][1])

### Tension Builds on Air

The clash between Gutfeld and Tarlov has been smoldering for some time. During a recent episode, their disagreement over political violence escalated when Tarlov argued it exists on both sides of the aisle. Gutfeld shot back sharply, contending that the evidence points to an asymmetry and refusing to entertain the “both sides” framing. ([TheWrap][2]) The exchange became heated, with Gutfeld accusing her of deflecting, and tensions visibly flared. ([TheWrap][2])

Some suggest this on‑air friction is only the tip of the iceberg. According to reports, Gutfeld’s dissatisfaction with Tarlov’s role has extended behind the scenes, culminating in his ultimatum. ([The News Scroll][1])

### Stakes for *The Five* and Fox

*The Five* is one of Fox News’ flagship programs, pulling in strong viewership night after night. Losing Gutfeld—or replacing a co‑host under his threat—risks destabilizing the panel’s chemistry and alienating parts of the audience.

Network executives now face a dilemma: side with Gutfeld, a ratings draw and central personality, or preserve the ensemble and risk losing him. Either path could have significant consequences for the show’s reputation and future. ([Story News][3])

### Public Reaction and Unanswered Questions

News of the ultimatum sparked a wave of reactions online. Some of Gutfeld’s fans praised his boldness, urging the network to choose him over any internal conflict. Others criticized the demand as heavy‑handed — arguing that *The Five* is built on lively debate, not retribution.

As of now, Fox News has remained mostly silent on the matter. Neither Gutfeld nor Tarlov has publicly confirmed the ultimatum in full detail. ([Story News][3]) The key questions remain:

* Will Fox side with Gutfeld or maintain its current panel structure?
* Could Tarlov be removed—or is that already underway?
* And ultimately: will Gutfeld follow through on his threat?

If he does walk away, it could mark one of the biggest shakeups in Fox’s prime time landscape. For now, all eyes remain on *The Five* and the network’s next move.